This is one of those loaded questions due to pro's and con's for both choices you could make. First let me explain what both are and what are their benefits.
401k's are employer sponsored plans that allow you to make a pre-tax contribution to your retirement. Most plans allow you to choose from a limited list of investment options. Typically there are 1 or 2 choices from most investment risk tolerances (growth, conservative, etc). The main benefit is unless your excessively wealthy or you make over a threshold you will have a hard time maxing out your 401k contributions each year. Also, with the advent of the new Roth 401k that more and more employers are moving to you can contribute to a Roth 401k and have tax free income in your retirement years. But that is another article on its own. The main benefit to a 401k is more and more employers are doing a 'match' with their 401ks. This is where they match how much you contribute to a certain percentage of what you make.
IRA's are usually individual plans that you setup on your own at your bank or a brokerage firm. The main benefit to an IRA is that you can choose your own vehicle for investment options. Also, if you by chance have maxed out your 401k you can then contribute to your IRAs as well. The main draw back is that they have a significantly lower contribution limit than 401ks do. Also, you don't get the benefit of an employer matching what you put in. You can choose to do a Roth IRA but that is dependant on your age and tax bracket.
Without straying too much from the question at hand though we will move to our current question. Check back for later posts for more in depth discussions of what an IRA is or what a Roth IRA is.
In short you should always contribute to your 401k first IF your employer does any kind of match. To illustrate we'll use two people.
Bill Pennypincher works for an employer who matches 50% of what you contribute up to 5% of your pay. So lets say that Bill makes $2,000 every pay period. Bill is smart and contributes 5% of his pay (to max his matching that the employer does). So he contributes $100 to his 401k plan. However, Bill's employer contributes an additional $50 to Bill's plan! So in just 1 day Bill had a 50% return on his money! If Bill is paid twice a month and he continues to contribute that way to his 401k, Bill's employer will have given him an extra $1,200! Talk about getting a raise for nothing! Bill's 401k would be worth (without calculating growth/loss) $3,600 at year end ($200 a month + $100 a month x 12 months).
Now we move to Mark Moneywaster. He is a coworker with Bill. He makes the same wage as Bill does. However Mark thinks that his employer is a crook and doesn't want any of his money in reach of his employer. So Mark decides to contribute to an IRA instead. Mark gets taxed on his full paycheck (while Bill got a $100 deduction). However, Mark can write his contributions off at tax time (so long as he doesn't make too much money). So Mark decides to contribute the same as Bill and puts 5% each pay period into his IRA. At year end he'll have $2,400 in his IRA.
Now lets say both are 30 years old. They plan on retiring by the time they're 50 (nece eh?). We'll assume that their plans grow at an average of 8% a year. In 20 years Bill will have $177,922 in his 401k while Mark will have $118,615. That is a difference of a little over fifty nine thousand dollars!!
A little different example is both want to retire when they reach $200,000 in retirement monies. Bill will be able to retire 4 years ahead of Mark.
So as you can see investing in a matcheable 401k always is better than your own IRA.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment